**[Dynamic]**  

**"Law-Tax Integration: Forging Compliance & Resolving Disputes" Seminar Successfully Convened in Guiyang**  

*Guiyang, June 28, 2025* – Under the guidance of the **Guizhou Certified Tax Agents Association**, co-hosted by **ChungRui Tax Group** and **Grandall Customs & Tax Business Committee & Legal Research Center**, and organized by **Guizhou ChungRui Xinda Tax Firm** and **Grandall Law Firm (Guiyang)**, the landmark seminar *"Legal-Tax Compliance and Tax-Enterprise Dispute Resolution from the Perspective of Law-Tax Integration Services"* concluded triumphantly. Over 80 legal, tax, and corporate professionals convened for a day of cross-disciplinary dialogue and actionable insights.  

---

### **Opening & Keynote Highlights**  

**Host:** Zheng Shihong, Managing Partner of Grandall (Guiyang) & President of Guizhou’s New Social Stratum Lawyers’ Association.  

**Keynotes:**  

1. **Liu Hui, President of Guizhou Certified Tax Agents Association** – Urged the tax profession to:  

   - Elevate professional standards to match national modernization goals.  

   - Strengthen collaboration with legal experts to fortify enterprise risk management.  

   - Champion innovation in tax services to support high-quality economic development.  

2. **Zhu Haoxing, Vice President of Guizhou Lawyers Association** – Emphasized that **"law-tax synergy is no longer optional but essential"** for navigating today’s volatile regulatory environment.  

**Moderated by Jiang Lingjun (GM, Guizhou ChungRui Xinda), four distinguished speakers delivered:**  

- **Prof. Lü Fan (Guizhou University)** – Dissected legal distinctions between **zero-yuan transfers vs. donations**, urging enterprises to integrate legal/tax counsel for risk mitigation.  

- **Prof. Huang Jiangyu (Guizhou University of Finance & Economics)** – Proposed a **"macro-meso-micro" compliance framework**, advocating **"three-dimensional legality tests"** (intent, policy benefit, statutory compliance) and **"dynamic, three-tier defense"** strategies.  

- **Cai Ming (Grandall Nanchang, Deputy Director of Customs & Tax Committee)** – Deconstructed **VAT fraud defense strategies**, stressing **substance-over-form** analysis in complex transactions.  

- **Jia Zong (GM, ChungRui Tax Group)** – Framed the **"three compliance challenges"** (policy volatility, stricter audits, dispute complexity) and championed **"law-tax co-review" mechanisms** to transform services from reactive to **full-cycle, proactive solutions**.  

---

### **Roundtable: Cross-Disciplinary Solutions**  

**Moderator:** Li Yao, Director of Grandall Customs & Tax Legal Research Center. Panelists included:  

- **Wang Min (Chongqing Ruijie Tax Firm)** – Advocated for **"tax-law co-defense"** in dispute resolution, blending tax expertise with litigation strategy.  

- **Jiang Lingjun (Guizhou ChungRui Xinda)** – Analyzed **"equity-debt hybrid"** cases, highlighting legal/tax interpretation gaps.  

- **Yuan Changhao (Guizhou Guida Law Firm)** – Promoted **non-litigation channels** (hearings, administrative reconsideration) as **cost-efficient alternatives** to litigation.  

- **He Zhen (Grandall Guiyang)** – Differentiated **tax evasion vs. calculation errors** via statutory interpretation and case law.  

- **Pan Ziqing (Grandall Guiyang)** – Critiqued **"tax clearance pre-procedure"** reforms, citing **barriers** like scarce tax-law talent and procedural hurdles.  

- **Xiao Jun (Finance Director, Guizhou Ronghui Real Estate)** – Stressed **"prevention over cure"**, urging enterprises to **co-create compliance** with tax authorities.  

---

### **Closing: Consensus & Call to Action**  

**Zhu Shan, President of Guizhou New Social Stratum Association & Supervisor of Guizhou Lawyers Association**, underscored the seminar’s alignment with **China’s modernization agenda**, urging professionals to **"turn insights into action"**.  

**Guo Dandan, Vice Chairman & Director of ChungRui Tax Group**, summarized the seminar’s **"3 Consensus, 2 Actions, 1 Vision"**:  

- **Consensus:**  

  1. Law-tax integration is **non-negotiable** for dispute resolution.  

  2. **"Legal qualification + tax quantification"** synergy is key to cross-disciplinary challenges.  

  3. **"Two-way compliance"** (enterprise + authority) must be rooted in **procedural justice**.  

- **Actions:**  

  1. Leverage the **Law-Tax Integration Service Center** to build a **western China law-tax ecosystem**.  

  2. Launch **"Law-Tax Clinics"** and **dispute early-warning systems** to operationalize consensus.  

- **Vision:**  

  - **"Let law-tax integration become the ‘safety cabin’ for enterprise compliance, anchoring tax governance modernization in mutual legal-tax validation."**  

---

### **Epilogue: ChungRui’s Commitment to Integration**  

The seminar’s success underscores **ChungRui Tax Group’s leadership** in anticipating industry trends and driving professional convergence. As regulatory complexity intensifies, ChungRui pledges to:  

- **Deepen law-tax integration** across service lines.  

- **Expand "tax-law-finance" fusion** to empower clients’ sustainable growth.  

- **Champion compliance innovation** as the bedrock of China’s economic resilience.  

**"In the harmony of law and tax, we find the rhythm of progress. ChungRui will continue to lead, integrate, and inspire."**